In A "What" vs "How" Fight, What Needs To Win in NPD

Back in school we were always told to show our workings when doing "sums", just in case we got the number wrong by simply overlooking an element of the calculation.  We were rewarded in part by the "How" as much as the "What".

But recently while working with a client on a new product, I realised how easy it is to fall for the "how" over the "what".

I know from my years of working on new products that the functional benefit (the what) is vastly more important than the emotional benefit (the how), as users have to establish the use & credibility of the new product's usage claims before they will buy into it. But the client & I spent too much time getting excited about the how and didn't answer the what sufficiently.

But what do I mean by the what (functional benefit) & how (emotional benefit)?  When developing a brand, the classic tool used is the brand essence wheel, which details the functional benefit on the top half of the wheel, asking questions like what does it do and what does it look like.  The BEW then asks what backs up the functional benefit, what makes the what credible by looking at the facts and symbols.

A classic example is the launch of the Gillette fusion in 2006. The functional benefit is not the five blades as they are the product features (the what it looks like) but that is gives men the most comfortable shave, because of its five blades which don't tug & pull.

The emotional benefit of the BEW (the lower half of the BEW) asks about how it makes you look and how it makes you feel, backed up by the personality of the brand.  The feel of the brand is very important to the longevity & profitability of the brand.  As an example, look what happened to Tango when they moved their "feel" away from edgy urban kids playing street hockey underneath the A40 (How many people actually remember that ad?!?!?) to the "You Know When You'Ve Been Tangoed" with the orange "portly gentleman" slapping the drinker on the chops with a football TV pundit style commentary - sales rocketed!

But the problem is not getting sucked into the trap of trying to create a sexy, glamorous TV commercial with the feel before the what is stuck into people's minds. After spending a fun afternoon developing a song platform for the launch of the brand, I realised that I had too fallen into the trap by focusing too much on the sparkly shinny bit of marketing and not the important "Ronseal" test element of marketing...

So with that, I'm going back to the client and challenge them to describe exactly how their product meets the functional needs of the consumers and how we describe that on the packaging...